Skip to content
Deja Who by Lyravant

Question list

Would you rather questions

Good would you rather questions offer two choices that are both tempting or both a little ridiculous, so people actually have to think. The best ones are quick to picture, like flying versus being invisible, or always being 10 minutes early versus 10 minutes late. They get even better when friends try to guess what you'd pick.

44 questions · updated October 28, 2026 by Lyravant

A would you rather question works when there is no obvious right answer. Superpowers and everyday trade-offs are the classics, while silly options like a giant hamster or a tiny elephant are great for a laugh.

Ask them around the table or in the group chat, or turn them into a guessing game: one person picks privately, and everyone else bets on what they chose. The "imagine if" questions at the end work the same way with open answers.

Play these with your group

Superpowers and magic

  1. Would you rather be able to fly or be invisible?
    • Fly
    • Be invisible
  2. Would you rather read minds or see the future?
    • Read minds
    • See the future
  3. Would you rather have teleportation or a time machine?
    • Teleportation
    • Time machine
  4. Would you rather have a rewind button or a pause button for life?
    • Rewind
    • Pause
  5. Would you rather breathe underwater or have super speed?
    • Breathe underwater
    • Super speed
  6. If you got a superpower tomorrow, what would you do first?
    • Help people
    • Pull pranks
    • Travel the world
    • Keep it quiet
  7. If you were a wizard, what spell would you learn first?
    • Instant cleanup
    • Summon snacks
    • Talk to animals
    • Fly a broom
  8. If you could keep one magical item, which would it be?
    • Invisibility cloak
    • Flying carpet
    • Magic wand
    • Bottomless backpack
  9. If you could pick one superpower, how would you rank these, top pick first?
    • Flying
    • Teleporting
    • Freezing time
    • Reading minds

Everyday trade-offs

  1. Would you rather always be 10 minutes early or 10 minutes late?
    • 10 minutes early
    • 10 minutes late
  2. Would you rather give up your phone or your bed for a month?
    • Phone
    • Bed
  3. Would you rather have 3-day weekends forever or a month off every summer?
    • 3-day weekends
    • A month off each summer
  4. Would you rather have every red light turn green or never wait in line?
    • Green lights
    • No lines
  5. Would you rather always have a full phone battery or perfect Wi-Fi?
    • Full battery
    • Perfect Wi-Fi
  6. Would you rather go to bed early or sleep in late, forever?
    • Early to bed
    • Sleep in late
  7. Would you rather only eat breakfast foods or only dinner foods?
    • Breakfast foods
    • Dinner foods
  8. Would you rather never feel cold or never feel sleepy?
    • Never cold
    • Never sleepy

Places and adventures

  1. Would you rather explore space or the deep ocean?
    • Space
    • Deep ocean
  2. Would you rather live in a treehouse or a houseboat?
    • Treehouse
    • Houseboat
  3. Would you rather spend a night locked in a theme park or a library?
    • Theme park
    • Library
  4. Would you rather live in a city that never sleeps or a quiet town?
    • City that never sleeps
    • Quiet town
  5. Would you rather live next to a bakery or a beach?
    • Bakery
    • Beach
  6. Would you rather camp under the stars or in a cozy cabin?
    • Under the stars
    • Cozy cabin
  7. Would you rather explore a haunted castle or an abandoned spaceship?
    • Haunted castle
    • Abandoned spaceship
  8. Would you rather solve a mystery or find a treasure?
    • Solve a mystery
    • Find a treasure
  9. Where would you rather spend one night? Rank them, favorite first.
    • Aquarium
    • Museum
    • Treehouse
    • Lighthouse

Just plain silly

  1. Would you rather have a pet dragon or a pet unicorn?
    • Dragon
    • Unicorn
  2. Would you rather always whisper or always shout?
    • Whisper
    • Shout
  3. Would you rather narrate your life out loud or have a laugh track?
    • Narrate out loud
    • Laugh track
  4. Would you rather have a giant hamster or a tiny elephant?
    • Giant hamster
    • Tiny elephant
  5. Would you rather have a pet sloth or a pet penguin?
    • Sloth
    • Penguin
  6. Would you rather have a talking car or a talking fridge?
    • Talking car
    • Talking fridge
  7. Would you rather have a theme song play when you enter or when you leave?
    • Entering
    • Leaving

Imagine if

  1. In a heist movie, what's your role?
    • Mastermind
    • Hacker
    • Getaway driver
    • The distraction
  2. Stranded on a desert island, what would you do first?
    • Build a shelter
    • Find food
    • Light a signal fire
    • Explore
  3. If aliens landed nearby, how would you react?
    • Say hi first
    • Hide
    • Film everything
    • Ask for a ride
  4. If you were invisible for a day, how much mischief would you cause?
  5. If you could pause time for an hour, what would you do?
    • Nap
    • Finish my to-do list
    • Explore frozen streets
    • Eat in peace
  6. If a genie granted you one tiny everyday superpower, what would it be?
  7. What would your superhero name be?
  8. What would you name your Wi-Fi network?
  9. If you wrote an autobiography, what would the title be?
  10. If you had to give up one food forever, which would it be?
  11. How long could you last without your phone on a desert island?

Turn these into a daily game

Deja Who asks your group one of these a day. One person answers, everyone else guesses or writes a fake answer to fool the others, and the reveal shows who knows you best. Free, in any phone browser, no app or account.

Play these with your group Try a sample round

How to play these as a guessing game

  1. Start a group on Deja Who and drop the link in your group chat. No app or account needed.
  2. Each day one friend gets a would you rather or what-if question and answers privately.
  3. Everyone else guesses their pick, or writes a fake answer for the open questions.
  4. At the reveal, see who called it, and track the score over the monthly season.

Questions people ask

What makes a good would you rather question?

Both options should be tempting, or both a bit absurd, so the choice is hard and fun to explain. Quick-to-picture choices work better than long, complicated setups.

Are these would you rather questions clean?

Yes. They avoid gross-out, dating and other touchy topics, so they are fine for teens, families and coworkers.

How do you play would you rather as a guessing game?

One person picks privately and everyone else guesses which option they chose, then you reveal. Deja Who runs this daily for your group from a link in any group chat.

What are good would you rather questions for a group chat?

Short two-option questions like flying versus invisibility or treehouse versus houseboat. They are easy to answer in one tap and start long side conversations.

More question lists

Games to play